This was a question asked 4 years ago and here was the answer
Don't dare ask for it to be updated in the current circumstances.
One assumes that the “best team” was in the top flight and so our researches have been restricted to this level. In the League’s history, there have been 95 teams who have played in the Premier Division (or the old Division 1) and so qualify for consideration. To narrow the search down even further we have restricted it to teams who have been at the top level for six seasons or more.
This leaves us with only 15 teams to be considered.
The next problem is how to measure “best”. If we look at the number of points gained we get the following result:
1. Wigston Town (CC) 869
2. WMC Braunstone 533
3. Birstall Eagle 496
4. Es Cana 385
5. Thurnby United (*) 318
6. Oadby Academicals 314
7. Advance Couriers (**) 286
8. Cedar Motors 255
9. Hunters 238
10. Turner & Jarvis (***) 198
11. Widdowson Haulage (****) 197
12. North Kilworth 181
13. Fleckney Old Crown 164
14. E L Cook Electrical (*****) 144
15. Scarlet Pimpernel 139
Of course, this does not take into account the number of games played and so a better measure might be the average points per game. Here goes:
1. WMC Braunstone 2.30
2. Cedar Motors 2.24
3. Advance Couriers 2.17
4. Hunters 2.09
5. Wigston Town (CC) 1.77
6. Oadby Academicals 1.71
7. Birstall Eagle 1.66
8. Widdowson Haulage 1.52
9. Es Cana 1.46
10. Fleckney Old Crown 1.37
11. Thurnby United 1.29
12. Scarlet Pimpernel 1.22
13. E L Cook Electrical 1.20
14. Turner& Jarvis 1.04
15. North Kilworth 1.04
But its not only about winning. What about loyalty to the club and to the League? Based on number of games played, this is the result
1. Wigston Town (CC) 491
2. Birstall Eagle 298
3. Es Cana 264
4. Thurnby United 247
5. WMC Braunstone 232
6. Turner& Jarvis 190
7. Oadby Academicals 184
8. North Kilworth 174
9. Advance Couriers 132
10. Widdowson Haulage 130
11=. E L Cook Electrical 120
11=. Fleckney Old Crown 120
13=. Cedar Motors 114
13=. Hunters 114
13=. Scarlet Pimpernel 114
My top three would be
1. Wigston Town (CC)
2. WMC Braunstone
3. Birstall Eagle
Which is your top team?
Does this trigger any memories? Let’s hear them.
*Thurnby United previously known as Humberstone and C & V United
** Advance Couriers previously known as Vikings Tun
***Turner & Jarvis also known as Advance Tapes
****Widdowson Haulage also known as Jasmine Diamonds and Aylestone Park Diamonds
*****E L Cook Electrical also known as Vintners and Old Crown